Return to Current Issue
Humor and Heartbreak: The Hysteria of Sylvia Plath
by Kat Rosa
Here is a story, one of those great literary legends we readers like to
believe are true: Sylvia Plath, reading her poem "Daddy" for the first time to
an audience - let's say, to her friend, the literary critic A. Alvarez, she
reaches the end, that great final line of "Daddy, daddy, you bastard, I'm
through," and immediately erupts in hysterical laughter. "Daddy," the hateful
rant of a bereaved child, the emptiness and orphanhood of a woman without a
father, the plea of the lost and eternally pained; "Daddy," the poem which
details Plath's suicide attempts and hints at her masochistic blood taint;
what could possibly be funny about this? The idea seems ludicrous. But when
reading "Daddy," or any of Plath's poetry or prose, I often find myself faced
with the (seemingly) inappropriate impulse to laugh and, following on its
heels, an aggressive poignancy. Plath's absurdity is a trademark and
necessary element in her energetic verse, and no poem illustrates this better
than "Daddy." From the first stanza,
You do not do, you do not do
Any more, black shoe
In which I have lived like a foot
For thirty years, poor and white,
Barely daring to breathe or Achoo.
ludicrous metaphors (a white foot in a black shoe) are paired with grave
meaning (a living entombment), just as she later pairs Luftwaffe and
gobbledygoo (42). I suppose it is odd to say that Plath is my favorite poet
because of her humor since she is known for her depression; she is the poster
child of tragic writers, having tried to kill herself once or twice (accounts
vary) and then succeeding that cold London winter of '63. But born of her
wry, acerbic wit and her lost, empty sadness is a manic energy that instills
in every cryptic metaphor, every beautiful line, every evocative image an
overwhelming sense of the writer.
When first faced with the question of my favorite poet, my thoughts flitted
quickly over scrambled lines in the rusted archives of my memory - T. S.
Eliot, Emily Dickinson, Wallace Stevens flew by - and I came to rest on:
The moon has nothing to be sad about,
Staring from her hood of bone.
She is used to this sort of thing.
Her blacks crackle and drag. (Plaths "Edge" 19-20)
Though Eliot, Dickinson, and Stevens all lack the specific energy and force
that appeals to me so much in Plath's poetry, they all share with her the
curious quality of reading like riddles. The first time actually the first
many times I read Plath's "Youre," which curiously succeeds "Daddy" in her
Ariel collection, I had absolutely no idea what she was describing. But and
here's the really special thing about Plath's poetry - I didn't need to know
the subject of the poem to tap into the speaker's feelings of elation, hope,
and anticipation, and the metaphoric images are all so arresting that I
continued to read and enjoy the poem even before fully understanding it. And
one day something clicked in my mind and I instantly saw what was there all
along. I suddenly realized what is "Gilled like a fish" and "looked for like
mail" (3, 10). It is curious that "Youre" should follow "Daddy" because the
latter is addressed to her father and deals with the suicidal depression his
death rendered her and the former is addressed to her unborn child and deals
with the joy and freshness of life. I remember being struck by the perfection
of the metaphors, as lines like "a common-sense / Thumbs-down on the dodo's
mode" suddenly shifted into the light (3-4). I might never understand exactly
what Plath meant by "Her blacks crackle and drag" at the end of "Edge," but
the sense of superior finality, detachment, and a welcomed end is clear as
crystal.
The level of energy in Sylvia Plath's poems varies from cold perfection as
in "Edge" to breaking hysteria as in "Daddy," but in the climax of "Fever
103°" it seems to hit an all-time high. Electricity and heat and light are
all throughout this poem; the speaker grows increasingly bright, and the fever
becomes a metaphor for a force both creative and destructive. Her fever is a
light; it consumes her, making her pure, allowing her to reach Paradise:
Darling, all night
I have been flickering, off, on, off, on [...]
Three days. Three nights.
Lemon water, chicken
Water, water make me retch.
I am too pure for you or anyone [...]
Does not my heat astound you. And my light.
All by myself I am a huge camellia
Glowing and coming and going, flush on flush.
I think I am going up,
I think I may rise -
The beads of hot metal fly, and I, love, I
Am a pure acetylene
Virgin
Attended by roses,
By kisses, by cherubim,
By whatever these pink things mean.
Not you, nor him.
Not him, nor him
(My selves dissolving, old whore petticoats)
To Paradise. (28-54)
Alvarez said that Plath's self-destructiveness was "the very source of her
creative energy... it was precisely a source of living energy, of her
imaginative, creative power," and we can see that precise idea here in the
fever (Hal Hager, author biographer). She is freed and purified, but the
fever is simultaneously destructive, taking its toll on the body and the mind,
as evident in the pink spots the speaker sees. These lines also show how
Plath uses poetic techniques, specifically enjambment and ellipsis, to make
the climax of the poem read with increasing energy. Reading these lines, my
mind always jumps to finish them; "I may go up" in flames, "I may rise" from
the ashes? on the third day? I often cannot stick with a single
interpretation. And thus, to me, Sylvia Plath's poetry can mean everything at
once in a strangely illuminating way.
Ultimately what I enjoy most in Sylvia Plath's poetry is the odd sense of
triumph that rounds off even her most tragic poems. Especially her most
tragic poems. "Daddy" ends in her putting to death her pained turmoil and
preoccupation with her father. "Fever 103°" ends with the speaker reaching
Paradise. "The box is only temporary" in "The Arrival of the Bee Box"
(36). "Stings" ends on a very similar image, a resurrected queen bee ("Is she
dead, is she sleeping?"), now flying "more terrible than she ever was, red /
Scar in the sky, red comet" (56-5. "Lady Lazarus," a poem that details
Plath's several suicide attempts even more gruesomely than "Daddy," has
perhaps the most triumphant ending. Early in the poem, Plath writes of a
failed suicide and the pain of realizing she's still alive.
Soon, soon the flesh
The grave cave ate will be
At home on me
And I a smiling woman.
I am only thirty.
And like a cat I have nine times to die.
This is Number Three.
What a trash
To annihilate each decade. (15-24)
She continues on to describe her subjugation as a freak show curiosity to
people who "just wanted to see what a girl who was crazy enough to kill
herself looked like" (The Bell Jar). Obviously a very low point in anyone's
life. And yet her last two stanzas are the most powerful and most triumphant
in all her poetry.
Herr God, Herr Lucifer,
Beware
Beware.
Out of ash
I rise with my red hair
And I eat men like air. (79-84)
Yes, I realize the irony of appreciating Sylvia Plath for her humor and her
triumphant endings. And, yes, I realize the inadequacy of the term "hysteria"
as applied to Plath, who used words with such cold efficient precision. But
these elements are there in her poetry, the humor, the hysteria, the triumph.
As I said above, the sense of the writer is front and center in these poems,
and she is empty and sad, laughing and triumphant.
Kat was born in the California Bay Area in 1983; she has been
living in exile in Davis for the past four years while finishing her B. A. in
English at the University of California. Her sad exile will end in her move to
San Francisco, where she looks forward to beginning her Masters in English
Literature and being told what to read for at least two more years.
Read More
|